Top 10 Best Reviewed Carry On Duffel Bags - Buyers Guide 2018

Most carry on duffel bags are great, but there are also some that aren't so fantastic.

It's there quite important that you spend some time comparing the different brands and models, so you can make sure you choose a duffel bag that matches your needs.

To help you choose, we have checked 12,910 reviews to find the best reviewed carry on duffel bags.

Check out the top 10 list below - and the top 3 most popular carry on duffel bags, if you just want to check out some of the most popular models (the models that most people end up buying).
How we rate the bags

We have checked thousands of reviews, so we can show you the weighted average rating of all the bags.

Using the average ratings, you can check what all the reviewers think instead of just viewing the subjective opinion of one specific reviewer.

It's much simplier to find the best bags that way.

Top 3 most popular carry on duffel bags 2018

Patagonia Black Hole duffel
Patagonia Black Hole
Rated 4.7 based on 1,317 reviews.
Osprey Ozone
Osprey Ozone
Rated 4.4 based on 396 reviews.
Tumi Alpha duffel
Tumi Alpha
Rated 4.4 based on 654 reviews.

Below is the top 10 list based on the thousands of reviews we have checked.

Top 10 carry on duffel bags 2018

Marmot Long Hauler duffel
Marmot Long Hauler
2 models available. [31048] and 38-110
Size 50 L (3051 CI)
Marmot logo
251 reviews

Patagonia Black Hole duffel
Patagonia Black Hole
5 models available. 120, 25, 45, 60 and 90
Size 25-120 L (1526-7323 CI)
Patagonia logo
1,317 reviews

The North Face Rolling Thunder duffel
The North Face Rolling Thunder
4 models available. 19, 22, 30 and 36
The north face logo
434 reviews

Patagonia Arbor duffel
Patagonia Arbor
4 models available. 26, 30, 32 and 60
Size 26-60 L (1587-3661 CI)
Patagonia logo
546 reviews

Gregory Alpaca duffel
Gregory Alpaca
7 models available. 120, 22, 28, 30, 45, 60 and 90
Size 120 L (7323 CI)
Gregory logo
7 reviews

Timbuk2 Wingman duffel
Timbuk2 Wingman
2 models available. [31093] and 2
Size 40 L (2441 CI)
Timbuk2 logo
197 reviews

The North Face Base Camp duffel
The north face logo
3,684 reviews

Under Armour Undeniable duffel
Under armour logo
3,224 reviews

Thule Chasm duffel
Thule Chasm
4 models available. 130, 40, 70 and 90
Size 90 L (5492 CI)
Thule logo
123 reviews

Osprey Ozone
Osprey Ozone
6 models available. 18, 22, 24, 28, 35 and 46
Size 24-70 L (1465-4272 CI)
Osprey logo
396 reviews

Eagle Creek No Matter What duffel
Eagle Creek No Matter What
3 models available. 20, 22 and 28
Size 38-77 L (2319-4699 CI)
Eagle creek logo
1,483 reviews

Eagle Creek Gear Warrior duffel
Eagle Creek Gear Warrior
4 models available. 22, 26, 29 and 32
Size 38-92 L (2319-5614 CI)
Eagle creek logo
387 reviews

Tumi Alpha duffel
Tumi logo
654 reviews

Timbuk2 Navigator duffel
Timbuk2 Navigator
Size 36 L (2197 CI)
Timbuk2 logo
148 reviews

Poler Classic duffel
Poler Classic
Size 28 L (1709 CI)
Poler logo
21 reviews

Outdoor Research Rangefinder duffel
Outdoor Research Rangefinder
3 models available. [31131], 20 and 23
Size 35 L (2136 CI)
Outdoor research logo
38 reviews

Herschel Novel duffel
Herschel Novel
Size 43 L (2624 CI)
Herschel logo

Review Summary

12,910 reviews of bags checked.

Average rating is 4.5 out of 5.
5 star
4 star
3 star
2 star
1 star

Top 10 carry on duffel bag brands

The 10 highest rated carry on duffel bag brands based on the 12,910 reviews we have checked + the highest rated bag from each brand.

BrandAverage ratingTop carry on duffel bag
Marmot4.8Marmot Long Hauler
Patagonia4.7Patagonia Black Hole
The North Face4.5The North Face Rolling Thunder
Under Armour4.5Under Armour Undeniable
Thule4.5Thule Chasm
Osprey4.4Osprey Ozone
Timbuk24.4Timbuk2 Wingman
Eagle Creek4.4Eagle Creek No Matter What
Tumi4.4Tumi Alpha
Poler4.3Poler Classic

Related Ranking Lists

Whether you are an explorer or just a frequent flyer, finding the right type of carry on luggage can be of the utmost importance. It can make it easier to travel and can even help you cut down on costs. This is why a carry on duffel bag can come in so handy. Of course, this is provided that you find the right one.

In this article, we take a look at all of the features that you need to have in a proper, carry on duffel bag. We also consider specific options that are perfectly suited for your individual situation. Here, you will learn all that you need to know about this type of travel bag. You can get started now.

Carry On Duffel Bags: A Guide to Choosing Them (Buyers Guide)

While duffel bags were once largely reserved for gyms or road trips, they have now transformed to even include carry on luggage as well. It is not difficult to see why. These type of bags are lightweight, strong, boast plenty of storage features, and are easy to carry around. It is not all that surprising that these are being toted around by travelers more frequently.

At the same time, it is not enough to pick up the first bag that you happen upon. Carry on duffel bags have to be chosen with a certain level of selectivity if you want to pick one that is actually worthy of being hauled around. Here, you will find out all that you need to know to be able to do so:

The Size Requirements

Now, when it comes to any type of carry on luggage, including carry on duffel bags, the first thing that must be addressed are the dimensions. This is because airlines have specific requirements as to the boundaries within which the dimensions can fall. While smaller bags will certainly be accepted, larger pieces of luggage may be required to be moved to checked luggage.

You should know that each airline has their own guidelines for what is acceptable and what is not. For the most part, though, you will find that most domestic airlines allow carry on luggage to have dimensions 22 x 14 x 9 inches or smaller. This means that as long as your luggage isn’t exceeding 45 linear inches, it will be allowed aboard.

The rules may be different with international airlines as well as your final destination. Due to this, it is always best to get a slightly smaller bag than what you would take on a domestic flight. Still, it is always best to check beforehand as rules regarding such matters can change quite suddenly.

Wheeled vs. No Wheels

Carry on duffel bags either have a wheel system or come without it. So, when thinking about buying this type of luggage, you are going to need to decide which one is best for you. This really boils down to the type of traveling that you are doing.

The main benefit of a wheeled duffel bag, of course, is that it easy to take around with you. Because you can rely on the wheels, you never have to deal with the weight of the bag. This comes in handy if you have to move from place to place, even when you have arrived at your destination.

The disadvantage of this type of bag is the weight. Since many airlines have a limit on how much you can take with you, a wheel system may mean that you have to pack less to adhere to these regulations. Also, if you do ever need to carry around your duffel bag, the wheels mean that you have additional weight to contend with.

What Do You Need Your Duffel Bag For?

The next question that you will need to ask yourself is just what you need your duffel bag for. See, carry on duffel bags come in all sorts of shapes, sizes, and designs. Due to this, you will need to match the bag with the purpose that you need it for.

For instance, if you want a duffel bag for business purposes, then you will have to think about the way that it needs to look. It should be medium sized and appear professional. Therefore, it should be made from a material such as leather or canvas. The purpose of these bags is to look sophisticated and to have proper organization features. Durability is less of a concern.

However, if you are looking for a travel duffel bag, this is a whole other story. These type of bags are great for exploring, camping, and similar outdoor activities. In this instance, durability is key as you are going to be carrying the bag through some fairly rough terrain. You may also want to look for one that is made from water-resistant or weatherproof material as well.

In addition to a travel bag, you may also be looking for one that can be used on a daily basis. You will find that a duffel backpack will suit this purpose especially well due to the comfortable suspension system associated with it. Also, this type of duffel bag is washable and easy to maintain as well.

In other instances, you may just be looking for a duffel bag that is as lightweight as possible. In addition to choosing a lighter material, you may also want to consider an unstructured bag. These can be folded or flattened when they are empty. Due to this, they weight quite a bit less than traditional duffel bags.

Organization Features

A long time ago, duffel bags were essentially made up of a main compartment where all of your belongings were placed. This meant that it was a bit difficult to organize anything. These days, however, carry on duffel bags have changed quite a bit. There are now several organization features available with them.

One of the most obvious, of course, are pockets. Carry on duffel bags have pockets on the inside as well as the outside. While the internal pockets can come in handy to separate your belongings, the external pockets can be used for items that you need to access quickly. You should understand that there is usually no way to secure these pockets so you should not keep any valuables here.

Some carry on duffel bags have adjustable dividers that will allow you to create sections within the main compartment. This can make it easier to separate your belongings and to be able to keep the bag a lot neater. It also gives you the option of living out of your suitcase, instead of unpacking.

Then there are bags that have built-in pull out shelves. This allows you to stretch out the shelves and hang them up on a hook or rack. This way, you can neatly arrange your clothes on each level. While these can be a bit bulky, they are great for staying organized. Some of the carry on duffel bags even come with special pouches or compartments for your shoes.

Durability and Weatherproofing

As mentioned, if you are planning on taking your carry on duffel bag everywhere you go, then it is worth it to invest in a more durable option. This starts with the material. Now, duffel bags can be made from many types of material although nylon is often the best choice, closely followed by polyester if you are looking for something a little lighter and most cost-effective.

If your carry on duffel bag will be experiencing a lot of wear and tear, then you are going to need a material that is abrasion resistant, at least to a degree. To minimize the damage done to your bag, you may want to consider ripstop material. This material will prevent rips from spreading through the fabric.

Another thing to think about would be moisture and rain. If you want to protect your belongings from spills or a drizzle, then you should get a carry on duffel bag that is made from water repellent material. For something more heavy duty, duffel bags that have been coated with waterproof coatings are a good option.

For those who will be spending a lot of time in the sun, duffel bags in hand, research materials that are UV resistant. Not only will these preserve the appearance of your bag, it will also ensure that it stays intact for longer.

When talking about durability, you cannot forget about the stitching. This is particularly important for anyone who likes to stuff their duffel bag with heavy items. Bags that have double or reinforced stitching will make sure that the seams of the bag stay together.

The Carrying System

Unlike with a carry on backpack, the carrying system of a carry on duffel bag is a bit different. Nonetheless, considering that at times you will need to lift the bag up, it is worth examining it. One of the first things to think about is the two handles on either side of the bag. There is often a mechanism for holding these together so that it is easier to carry. You should make sure that this is made from a material that you can grip easily. It should also be comfortable as you may need to hold onto your bag for quite a while.

Then, there is the shoulder strap that goes diagonally around your torso. Typically, you should look for a wider strap as this will help to distribute the weight of the bag more easily. There should also be a small padded area where the strap will rest against your shoulder. This feature will prevent the material from digging into your skin. The length of this strap should also be adjustable so that you can alter it to suit your specific height.

This is all that you need to know concerning carry on duffel bags. There are plenty of options available to you so it is important to choose wisely.

Comments are closed.