Top 40 Best Reviewed Carry-On Luggage - Buyers Guide 2018


Few things feel better than flying with only carry-on luggage. It's easier and faster to board the plane when you don't need to check in luggage - and you also get out of the airport much faster when you don't have to wait for your luggage (or worry about it, if it has disappeared).

Luckily there are lots of models to choose from. It pays to spend some time comparing all these models, so you can make sure you choose a bag that is of great quality and that match your needs in relation to size and features.

To help you choose, we have checked 34,467 reviews to find the best reviewed carry-on luggage.

Check out the top 40 list below - and the top 3 most popular carry-on luggage, if you just want to check out some of the most popular models (the models that most people end up buying).
How we rate the bags

We have checked more than 800,000 reviews, so we can show you the weighted average rating of thousands of bags.

Using the average ratings, you can check what all the reviewers think instead of just viewing the subjective opinion of one specific reviewer.

It's much simplier to find the best bags that way.



Top 3 most popular carry-on luggage 2018


Patagonia Black Hole
Patagonia Black Hole
Rated 4.7 based on 1,254 reviews.
Delsey Helium
Delsey Helium
Rated 4.5 based on 3,514 reviews.
Travelpro Platinum Magna
Travelpro Platinum Magna
Rated 4.4 based on 952 reviews.

Below is the top 40 list based on the thousands of reviews we have checked.


Top 40 carry-on luggage 2018


Lowe Alpine AT
Lowe Alpine AT
Size 40 L (2441 CI)
Lowe alpine logo
5.0
2 reviews

High Sierra Symmetry
High Sierra Symmetry
2 models available. 12 and 18
High sierra logo
5.0
1 review

Samsonite Leverage
Samsonite logo
5.0
1 review

Burton Wheelie
Burton Wheelie
2 models available. [31109] and 63
Size 40 L (2441 CI)
Burton logo
4.8
90 reviews

Patagonia Black Hole
Patagonia Black Hole
5 models available. 120, 25, 45, 60 and 90
Size 25-120 L (1526-7323 CI)
Patagonia logo
4.7
1,254 reviews

Osprey Meridian
Osprey Meridian
4 models available. 22, 28, 60 and 75
Size 75 L (4577 CI)
Osprey logo
4.7
68 reviews

Patagonia Headway
Patagonia Headway
4 models available. 22, 40, 45 and 70
Size 22-70 L (1343-4272 CI)
Patagonia logo
4.6
222 reviews

The North Face Rolling Thunder
The North Face Rolling Thunder
4 models available. 19, 22, 30 and 36
The north face logo
4.6
427 reviews

Eagle Creek Lync System
Eagle Creek Lync System
Size 36 L (2197 CI)
Eagle creek logo
4.6
141 reviews

Eagle Creek Morphus
Eagle Creek Morphus
2 models available. 22 and 30
Size 48 L (2929 CI)
Eagle creek logo
4.6
28 reviews

Eagle Creek Load Warrior
Eagle Creek Load Warrior
7 models available. 20, 22, 25, 26, 28, 29 and 32
Size 42 L (2563 CI)
Eagle creek logo
4.5
180 reviews

Pacsafe Duffelsafe
Pacsafe Duffelsafe
5 models available. [31124], at100, at120, at45 and at80
Size 80 L (4882 CI)
Pacsafe logo
4.5
31 reviews

Tumi Alpha
Tumi logo
4.5
874 reviews

Sakroots Artist Circle
Sakroots logo
4.5
3,277 reviews

Osprey Sojourn
Osprey Sojourn
5 models available. 22, 25, 45, 60 and 80
Size 80 L (4882 CI)
Osprey logo
4.5
82 reviews

Thule Subterra
Thule Subterra
5 models available. 23, 25, 30, 34 and 40
Size 90 L (5492 CI)
Thule logo
4.5
118 reviews

Ogio Renegade
Ogio Renegade
Size 16 L (976 CI)
Ogio logo
4.5
984 reviews

Eagle Creek Gear Warrior
Eagle Creek Gear Warrior
4 models available. 22, 26, 29 and 32
Size 38-92 L (2319-5614 CI)
Eagle creek logo
4.5
268 reviews

Eagle Creek Tarmac
Eagle Creek Tarmac
5 models available. 22, 25, 26, 29 and 30
Size 120 L (7323 CI)
Eagle creek logo
4.5
259 reviews

Pacsafe Toursafe
Pacsafe Toursafe
5 models available. [31125], at21, at25, at29 and exp34
Size 42 L (2563 CI)
Pacsafe logo
4.5
50 reviews

Delsey Helium
Delsey logo
4.5
3,514 reviews

Timbuk2 Wingman
Timbuk2 Wingman
2 models available. [31093] and 2
Size 40 L (2441 CI)
Timbuk2 logo
4.5
295 reviews

High Sierra Powerglide
High Sierra Powerglide
Size 39 L (2380 CI)
High sierra logo
4.4
3,564 reviews

Travelpro Maxlite
Travelpro Maxlite
Size 45 L (2746 CI)
Travelpro logo
4.4
3,160 reviews

High Sierra AT8
High sierra logo
4.4
19 reviews

Travelpro Crew
Travelpro Crew
3 models available. 10, 11 and 22
Size 81 L (4943 CI)
Travelpro logo
4.4
637 reviews

Osprey Ozone
Osprey Ozone
6 models available. 18, 22, 24, 28, 35 and 46
Size 24-70 L (1465-4272 CI)
Osprey logo
4.4
201 reviews

Eagle Creek No Matter What
Eagle Creek No Matter What
3 models available. 20, 22 and 28
Size 38-77 L (2319-4699 CI)
Eagle creek logo
4.4
1,235 reviews

Travelpro Platinum Magna
Travelpro logo
4.4
952 reviews

Thule Crossover
Thule Crossover
5 models available. 25, 32, 38, 40 and 87
Size 25-87 L (1526-5309 CI)
Thule logo
4.4
771 reviews

Timbuk2 Copilot
Timbuk2 Copilot
3 models available. 20, 22 and 28
Timbuk2 logo
4.4
80 reviews

Pacsafe Vibe
Pacsafe Vibe
7 models available. 100, 150, 20, 25, 30, 325 and 40
Size 4-40 L (244-2441 CI)
Pacsafe logo
4.4
135 reviews

Pacsafe Venturesafe
Pacsafe Venturesafe
7 models available. 15, 150, 22, 25, 30, 325 and 45
Size 25 L (1526 CI)
Pacsafe logo
4.4
392 reviews

IT Luggage Megalite
It luggage logo
4.3
7,173 reviews

Samsonite Winfield
Samsonite logo
4.3
2,991 reviews

Poler Classic
Poler Classic
Size 28 L (1709 CI)
Poler logo
4.3
24 reviews

Eagle Creek Adventure
Eagle Creek Adventure
3 models available. 22, 25 and 28
Size 41-112 L (2502-6835 CI)
Eagle creek logo
4.3
355 reviews

OGIO Bandit
OGIO Bandit
Size 28 L (1709 CI)
Ogio logo
4.2
597 reviews

Dakine Valise
Dakine Valise
3 models available. 100, 35 and 65
Size 35 L (2136 CI)
Dakine logo
4.2
15 reviews

High Sierra Winslow
High Sierra Winslow
3 models available. [31076], 22 and 34
High sierra logo

Review Summary

34,467 reviews of bags checked.

Average rating is 4.4 out of 5.

Related Ranking Lists



There are certain items that you simply can entrust to checked luggage. If you want to keep important things close to you (or are just going on a short trip) then carry on luggage is the way to go. The thing with this type of bag, though, is that there are lots of rules and restrictions surrounding it. All of this can make it quite confusing when it comes time to choose one.

Well, we understand your frustration completely which is why we decided to clarify this selection process for you. You will be able to find all of the information that you require to choose a high quality and long lasting piece of carry on luggage:

What You Need to Know About Selecting Carry On Luggage (Buyers Guide)

When it comes to choosing carry on luggage, you quickly realize just how many details and features that you need to be aware of. With most other types of bags, it is typically down to personal preference as well as identifying which one is the best. With carry on luggage, though, there is a lot more to think about since you also have to take airline guidelines into consideration as well. Of course, you don’t need to worry about any of this as the following article has you covered:

Types of Carry On Luggage

There are various styles and designs of carry on luggage to select from:

Carry On Backpack

You will see most people walking around with a carry on backpack strapped to their shoulder. The main draw of this type of luggage is that it is comfortable to carry, has numerous compartments, and isn’t as rigid as some of the other styles of hand luggage. Not to mention, most people now travel with their laptops and laptop backpacks are one of the easiest ways to pack your digital devices.

Carry On Duffel

Carry on duffel bags are also rather common among flyers. These are sturdy bags that are able to contain a larger quantity of items. This makes them ideal for people headed out on short trips and who want to carry all of their baggage as hand luggage. Duffel bags have a versatile design which fits in with a number of environments.

Carry On Suitcase

The great thing about taking a carry on suitcase with you is that you get to neatly organize all of your belongings. They are also good for protecting any delicate items as they tend to be a little bit more structured than other types of bags. Suitcases are available either as soft shell cases or hard shell cases.

Carry On Briefcases

A carry on briefcase is just what you need for business travel. These bags look professional and have just enough space for a laptop, other digital devices, and documents. There is also plenty of organization features as well.

Things to Consider

Now, there are some commonalities among the types of bags that you will need to think about:

Wheels or No Wheels?

All carry on backpacks, duffel bags, briefcases, and suitcases can either be without wheels or have wheels. So, this is something that you will have to factor in when making your decision. Now, the upside of having a wheeled bag is that it is easier to take around with you. This way, you will not have to feel the strain of the weight that you have packed.

Of course, the wheel system and the wheels themselves add both weight as well as bulk to the bag in question. This can prove to be a bit of a problem as these are factors that you need to minimize with carry on luggage. In the end, the decision will need to suit your preferred way to travel.

If you do decide to go with wheels, then you will need to pick between bags with two wheels and those with four. The bags with two wheels are great for practically all kinds of flooring, including pavement and uneven ground. They are also durable and the wheels are recessed in the bag so that they don’t take up too much space.

Four wheeled bags are also known as spinners. The great thing about four wheels is that you can simply push them along without making much of an effort. They also work well when traveling through small spaces. The only issue is that the wheels are fixed to the outside of the suitcase making them vulnerable. The wheels also take up additional space.

Women or Men Specific?

When it comes to carry on luggage, there aren’t really pieces specifically for men or for women. There may be colors and designs that are targeted towards certain genders but that really, is where the differences lie. With backpacks, however, you may come across women specific packs. These are made for the smaller frames of women and can be useful for those who are a bit petite.

Size

There is no denying that getting the size right with your carry on luggage is of the utmost importance. If it is too large, then it will not be allowed onboard with you. The tricky part is actually figuring out what size that you should get. One thing you should not do is believe stores or sites that claim to have ‘official carry on sizes’. This is because there is no official size. Each airline determines what size your hand luggage should be and you will need to adhere to these rules. So, while some airlines will insist that you only bring small carry on bags with you, others may have more relaxed rules.

In most cases, domestic airlines and flights will allow a carry on bag that is no longer than 22 inches. The bag should also have a width less than 14 inches and the depth should not be greater than 9 inches. It is important to remember that these dimensions are including the handles, wheels, and any other external features of your bag as well.

There aren’t fixed size rules for international travel either and these, too, are dependent on the airline that you are traveling on. The dimensions are quite similar to the domestic measurements and only differ by a couple of inches. Some airlines quote linear inches rather than individual dimensions. Linear inches refers to the total calculation of the length, width, and depth of the bag.

In the end, it is best to simply check with the airline that you will be using. They will be the only ones equipped to answer this question accurately. It is actually a good idea to do so every time that you book a flight. Lots of airlines change their size requirements quite regularly.

Underseat Luggage

While carry on luggage can seem like an all-encompassing term, you should stop and think about where is that you want to store your bag. The two main options are in the overhead compartment or under the seat in front of you. Now, if you want to keep your bag beneath the seat, then there are entirely different dimensions to think about.

Here too, the size is dependent on the airline. This, of course, is because the bag must be slightly smaller than the space that is available under the seat. Since seat measurements differ with each airline, you will need to do your homework ahead of time. Usually, though, if the bag is less than 42 linear inches, it should fit well under here.

Weight

Once you have dealt with the size of the bag, the next thing that you will have to figure out is the weight. Carry on luggage has weight restrictions as well. Once again, it all depends on which airline that you are flying on. Typically, though the allowed weight ranges from about 10 to 18 pounds.

The reason that you need to think about this is because most carry on bags weigh upwards of a pound. The bigger and more durable the bag, the heavier it will be. So, if you want to maximize on how much you can take with you in your bag, you will need to keep an eye on the weight of the empty bag as well.

Materials

The material of your carry on luggage can be important for two purposes – weight and durability. With backpacks, duffel bags, and soft shell suitcases, your biggest choice will be between polyester and nylon. If you want to keep the weight as low as possible, then polyester will probably be a better option as it tends to be lighter. It is also good for anyone looking for cheap carry on luggage as these bags tend to cost less.

For durability, though nylon is the clear winner. If you want a bag that will not tear or wear away easily, then you may want to opt for a model that uses either ripstop nylon or ballistic nylon. These are abrasion resistant and can be used for a long time without showing signs of damage.

If you are looking for hard shell suitcases then some form of plastic is typically commonly available. PVC plastic quite light but also gets dented relatively easily so it isn’t a great idea if you do a lot of heavy duty traveling. The ABS plastic is a great deal stronger but predictably weighs more as well. You may also find hard shell suitcases that are made from aluminum. While they are the strongest of all the options, they also weigh the most.

If you want a bag that is more for form rather than function, canvas and leather are other options you can turn to. Of course, you will need to be aware that these don’t stand up well to heavy use and may begin to look worn out after a few trips. With proper maintenance, though, they could last for some years.

This is the extent of what you need to know about selecting carry on luggage for your next trip.


Last updated on December 14, 2017

Comments are closed.

Tweet
Share
Share
Email
Pin