Top 10 Best Chalk Bags in 2018

As a climber, you probably know all to well that chalk bags aren’t all the same. Some feels great to use, while others have openings that are too small or annoying decorations that get in the way while climbing.

At the same time, the quality of the bags aren’t all the same. It therefore pays to spend some time checking the different brands and models, so you can end up choosing a great bag!

Having checked hundreds of chalk bag reviews, we can say that the Petzl Sakapoche is the best choice for most people.


Petzl Sakapoche

Petzl Sakapoche

The best reviewed chalk bag
Rated 4.91 out of 5

Check Price


PS: We have checked 1,291 reviews to make this top 10 list!
RankModelRating
1Petzl SakapochePetzl Sakapoche4.91Check Price
2Petzl SakaPetzl Saka4.91Check Price
3DMM EdgeDMM Edge4.74Check Price
4Black Diamond GymBlack Diamond Gym4.61Check Price
5Edelrid Cosmic TwistEdelrid Cosmic Twist4.47Check Price
6Metolius Access FundMetolius Access Fund4.40Check Price
7Black Diamond MojoBlack Diamond Mojo4.30Check Price
8Two Ogres Basique V24.22Check Price
9Mammut OphirMammut Ophir4.19Check Price
10Arcteryx ApertureArcteryx Aperture3.93Check Price

How we rate the bags

We have checked 1,291 chalk bag reviews, so we can show you the weighted average rating of all the bags.

Using the average ratings, you can check what all the reviewers think instead of just viewing the subjective opinion of one specific reviewer.

It’s much simplier to find the best bags that way.


Not sure what chalk bags to choose? Read on as we are going to take a closer look at each bag!


1 – Petzl Sakapoche

5 review stars Rating 4.91 based on 11 reviews

Check Price

Petzl Sakapoche


Here’s what the reviewers think about the Petzl Sakapoche:

Reviewers like these things about the Petzl Sakapoche

  • Many users liked that it’s lightweight and sturdy with enough room to get the hands inside to grab the chalkbag.
  • Other reviewers loved how the cinch closure keeps the inside of the gear bag chalk free when not in use, and keeps it from spilling on the gym couches and floor.
  • One user praised the bag for its well-designed,very functional pocket.
  • Others appreciate the presence of a tiny elastic loop to hold the brush which can serve as an attachment point.
  • Some liked the gusseted feature of the pocket,allowing it to expand,without impinging on the chalk compartment.
  • Others loved how the opening is big enough to get things in and out, but not so open that things are likely to fall out if left open.
  • One described it as the best dog treat and bag holder he’s ever found.
  • One reviewer who’ve used the bag for a while said that it’s very well-made nd has stood up to a good deal of abuse already with no signs of wear.
  • A user commented that the bag is built like you will never need to buy another bag again.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • A user noted that when attached, it’s prone to flap around a bit, letting chalk fall out.
  • A reviewer said it doesn’t sit well on the floor so, the chalk falls out with the smallest movements on the bounding mats.


2 – Petzl Saka

5 review stars Rating 4.91 based on 24 reviews

Check Price

Petzl Saka


Here’s what the reviewers think about the Petzl Saka:

Reviewers like these things about the Petzl Saka

  • Most users said that the Petzl Saka Chalkbag is a basic bag perfect for the climbing gym or bouldering.
  • Many users said that it seals off completely and holds its shape for easy access.
  • Many other users said that it is compact, lightweight, and has been extremely durable so far.
  • Reviewers said that it’s a simple attractive chalk bag that gets the job done.
  • Most reviewers said that it seals it nicely, and opens big enough for your hands.
  • Some users said that it has a nylon lining on the top so you can slide all your chalk in the bag and it doesn’t get too messy.
  • Some other users said that it holds my chalk and I can fit my hands in there.
  • Buyers said that they loved the buckle drawstring as its super easy to adjust and makes for a comfortable fit.
  • Buyers also said that the inside liner is also smooth.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • One user complained that the bag is not much bigger.
  • Another user complained that if you have larger hands you should get a bigger bag.


3 – DMM Edge

5 review stars Rating 4.74 based on 53 reviews

Check Price

DMM Edge


Here’s what the reviewers think about the DMM Edge:

Reviewers like these things about the DMM Edge

  • Many users thought the carry handles and the stable base make it a cinch to use around the blocks.
  • Some reviewers like how the double-seal chalk closure keeps your chalk where they want it.
  • Others love how it stands upright by itself with no problem.
  • Many users thought it has plenty of room for wallet,phone, keys, etc.
  • Others like how they can easily get two hands inside the bucket to chalk up.
  • many users enjoy its multiple pockets and brush holders.
  • Others find it large enough to hold at least 4-5 blocks of chalk.
  • Some owners thought that the best part is the ridged structure of the opening that keeps it from flopping over.
  • Others find the side pockets and tightening strings awesome.
  • Some reviewers find it very convenient for the boulder gym.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • Others find the 2 brush holder loops too small to slip brushes through.


4 – Black Diamond Gym

4.5 review stars Rating 4.61 based on 18 reviews

Check Price

Black Diamond Gym


Here’s what the reviewers think about the Black Diamond Gym:

Reviewers like these things about the Black Diamond Gym

  • A reviewer thought that the Black Diamond Gym gear bag is lightweight.
  • Users mentioned that it is big enough to hold several items in place.
  • Reviewers pointed out that it is equipped with an organizer panel which can hold tablets and phones.
  • According to some reviewers, its 1200D polyester fabric material makes the backpack durable.
  • Other reviewers noted its TPU coating makes it resistant to water.
  • They also noticed that they could close the bag securely through a metal buckle.
  • Some users recommend its use for those who are into climbing.
  • Others noted that it is also a great gym bag as well.
  • Testers noted that its one-handed open system makes packing easier.
  • Several reviewers indicated that the elastic pocket of the bag keeps gears separate from the cord.
  • Another user thought that the bag is comfortable to wear due to its padded shoulder straps.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • A reviewer thought that the bag is not practical for cyclists.
  • A few other reviewers noted that it does not hold a lot of equipment for weekend activities.


5 – Edelrid Cosmic Twist

4.5 review stars Rating 4.47 based on 35 reviews

Check Price

Edelrid Cosmic Twist


Here’s what the reviewers think about the Edelrid Cosmic Twist:

Reviewers like these things about the Edelrid Cosmic Twist

  • Most users said that the rim of the chalk bag is really sturdy and keeps its round shape really well.
  • Many users said that can move their hand in and out of the bag without a problem.
  • Users praised the fact that the inside is lined with fleece,.
  • Several users said that the top of the bag is lined with some hard wire which really seals it shut.
  • Some other reviewers said that they love Edelrid Cosmic as it comes with a waist belt.
  • Many users praised the fact that when they turned the bag upside-down and shook it not a speck of dust fell out.
  • Some of the users said that they use this bag for weightlifting chalk.
  • Reviewers have mentioned that the material is of good quality.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • One user complained that the waist clip was a bit small.
  • Another user said that the zipper does not close as tightly.


6 – Metolius Access Fund

4.5 review stars Rating 4.40 based on 6 reviews

Check Price

Metolius Access Fund


Here’s what the reviewers think about the Metolius Access Fund:

Reviewers like these things about the Metolius Access Fund

  • Most users said that they are very happy with this and it is just as easy of use.
  • Reviewers also said that it has great quality, feels like it will last forever.
  • They also said that it looks cool and it serves its function well.
  • Users said that it holds a good amount of chalk.
  • One great feature praised by many users is that you can take the belt off and attach it to your gear haul loop with a biner put a brush on it in the brush holder.
  • Users also said that it has a big mouth so I never have problems getting my whole hand in.
  • They also said that the drawstring works well.
  • Most reviewers sad that the belt given with it does its job and doesn’t loosen.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • Some users complained that the material used to close the top with the drawcord is not good at keep chalk dust.
  • Another user complained that the elastic which keeps the bag closed seems a little lower than it should be compared to other chalk bags.


7 – Black Diamond Mojo

4.5 review stars Rating 4.30 based on 622 reviews

Check Price

Black Diamond Mojo


Here’s what the reviewers think about the Black Diamond Mojo:

Reviewers like these things about the Black Diamond Mojo

  • According to users, the Black Diamond Mojo has a simple yet efficient design.
  • Other users pointed out that it is resistant to abrasion due to its material.
  • Testers noted that the bag is durable.
  • Reviewers mentioned that the bag includes a webbing belt with a quick-release buckle.
  • They noticed that it does not leak chalk.
  • Users said that the bag cinches tight.
  • Other reviewers also found that its drawstring works as designed.
  • According to some reviewers, the bag is portable.
  • Testers noted that the bag can still be accessed even when climbing.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • A tester said that the bag is smaller than expected.
  • A reviewer thought that the top material is a little too stiff.


8 – Two Ogres Basique V2

4.5 review stars Rating 4.22 based on 268 reviews

Check Price


Here’s what the reviewers think about the Two Ogres Basique V2:

Reviewers like these things about the Two Ogres Basique V2

  • Most users said that it holds chalk well and has a very pleasant faux-fur lining.
  • Many users mentioned that the fabric is thick and durable.
  • Users said that there is an adjustable-length strip of webbing with a plastic fastener that could conceivably be a waistband.
  • Some other users said that the workmanship seems to be just fine.
  • Several users said that the material for the inside of the bag is soft and nice.
  • Reviewers also said that the zippered pocket is useful to stash small things.
  • They also mentioned that the drawstring is in the perfect place to secure my items into the bag.
  • One great feature mentioned by many users that it has a drawstring that cinches the top all the way closed to prevent the escape of chalk.
  • Another great feature mentioned by the buyers is that that it clips around their waist.
  • Buyers also said that there is a pocket to throw small stuff in.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • Some users complained that the material for the outside of the bag was rough.
  • One user complained that it often collapses in on itself, especially the opening, making it difficult to chalk up effectively.
  • Another user complained that the brush loop started unraveling within a couple of weeks.


9 – Mammut Ophir

4 review stars Rating 4.19 based on 80 reviews

Check Price

Mammut Ophir


Here’s what the reviewers think about the Mammut Ophir:

Reviewers like these things about the Mammut Ophir

  • Some users described it as a simple and robust base mat that can be easily rolled into a rope bag.
  • Many users thought it’s perfectly light and compact.
  • A lot of users said that because it’s streamlined, it’s not bulky and annoying to walk with.
  • Some hikers love that the straps are simple, no extra bulk with padding or big buckles.
  • A lot of reviewers like that it’s quick and easy to stow and pack up.
  • Many hikers like that it can either be rolled up or kept in a flat envelope shape.
  • One user said that the unique design of this bag allows them to carry climb rope into remote work sites without hurting their shoulders.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • Others find the shoulder strap a bit thin.


10 – Arcteryx Aperture

4 review stars Rating 3.93 based on 129 reviews

Check Price

Arcteryx Aperture


Here’s what the reviewers think about the Arcteryx Aperture:

Reviewers like these things about the Arcteryx Aperture

  • Most reviewers said that it’s sturdy, has no string to break and comes with a belt.
  • Some users said that it has one-handed opening means you can be on the wall and easily get into it if you’ve forgotten to open beforehand.
  • Some other users said that it keeps all their chalk where it belongs.
  • Users also said that it is light, small package.
  • Other users said that it is really great bag, excellent design.
  • They said that it contains chalk unbelievably well.
  • Many users also said that it feels so smooth and weightless without the drawstring and extra material.
  • Most buyers also said that it is very efficient and sleek feeling and it never spews chalk into my bag.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • Some users complained that it would be a bit small for guys.
  • One user complained that the button would be on the front instead of the side that touches your back.

More exciting bags


You might also be interested in these bag categories!


Buyer’s guide to chalk bags


Whether you on a climbing wall or trying to scale the rocks out in nature, the one thing that you can’t do without is chalk. So, by that logic, you desperately need a chalk bag to make sure that you get the right amount of chalk when you need it. Chalk bags, though, are in a league of their own and you will need a little help to figure out which one you should invest in.

Well, we put together a guide to help you find the answers to all of these questions that you may have about chalk bags. Armed with the right information, you will be able to find just what you need. Read this article to get an in-depth look at this type of bag.

All You Need to Know About Selecting a Chalk Bag

While you may have given a lot of thought to the type of chalk that you take with you on your climbing adventures, you may have spared less attention to your chalk bag. After all, a bag is a bag, right? Well, when it comes to chalk bags, this is simply not the case. You need a bag that will suit your climbing location, style, and even your physique! If this seems like too much of information for you to take in, don’t worry. Here you will be able to find an easier way to decide on which chalk bag is best suited to your requirements:

Chalk Bag Types

Climbing chalk bag types come in two shapes and they are each suited for a different purpose and activity. They are:

  • Cylindrical bags: as the name implies, these bags are elongated and in the shape of a cylinder. This structure gives them a larger reservoir which is why they are often used on longer climbs.
  • Tapered bags: these bags have a more tapered end which means that they can’t hold as much chalk. The main advantage of these bags is that they will allow for technical moves without spilling over.

Chalk Bag Sizes

One of the next things that you will need to think about is the size of your chalk bag. Chalk bags are available in small, standard, and buckets. The small refers to the tiniest of the bag sizes. It is carried around your waist while rock climbing. These bags are so small that oftentimes, you can’t fit in more than the top half of their hands.

The standard size tends to be more common although it, too, is worn around your waist while climbing. Here, you are able to fit your whole hand in and as such are able to get even your arms coated in chalk if needed.

The bucket is the largest of the bunch. Also known as a clay pot, this is essentially a community bouldering chalk bag. It is kept on the ground and can be used by numerous people at once.

Chalk Bag Materials

The material that the chalk bag is made of plays a rather important role in your decision as well. This is because the fabric that it is constructed from will determine just how durable the bag actually is. The most common materials used for this purpose are nylon and canvas.

Nylon

The main perks of using nylon bags are that the material is lightweight and also quite durable. This way, you will be able to carry a larger amount of chalk with you and not feel the weight as much. If you are looking to make a serious investment and want a chalk bag that will really last you a while, you should look for one that is made from rip-stop nylon fabric. This material is abrasion resistant which makes it quite tough. At the same time, should a rip appear in the bag, this fabric is able to stop it from spreading.

Canvas

Canvas, too, is quite strong and sturdy which makes it a good choice for rough terrain. At the same, it requires thicker fibers to achieve this level of strength and so can be a tad heavier to carry. Typically, canvas absorbs moisture very quickly but if you opt for a bag that is made from waxed canvas, then you will be able to protect your chalk from moisture as well.

Other Materials

Chalk bags can be made of plenty other materials such as polyester and leather. Prior to choosing bags that are made from this type of fabric, make certain that they are able to match up to your personal requirements. Typically, bags made from leather are often used as buckets since they can’t withstand too much of wear and tear.

The Lining

The one thing that you should check for inside your chalk bag is a lining. This lining is mostly made up of fleece and is used because of its softness. The lining of the bag holds onto the chalk powder which makes it easier for you to spread it more evenly on your hands.

Rim and Closure Features

Without a doubt, you will need to look for a chalk bag that has a stiffened rim. This keeps the bag open for as long as you need it and makes it easy for you to dip in, whenever you need it. The feature eliminates a lot of hassle while you are climbing.

The closures on your chalk bag are also incredibly important. After all, these are what will determine whether or not you get chalk on everything that you own. Hands down, the most commonly utilized closure is the drawstring cord and the toggle. The string can be pulled to clinch the mouth shut and to keep it secured. It is also relatively easy to open up the bag again.

There are some manufacturers that have come up with closures that are different to this traditional feature. From twist tops to clic clac closures, there are now more options available to you. If you really want to minimize the amount of mess that you make though, you should look for dustproof closures.

Chalk Bag Attachment System

The first question that you will need to ask yourself when deciding on an attachment system is how you want to carry your chalk bag. Do you want to carry it around your waist and easily move it from the back to the front and vice versa? Do you want to carry other gear and have your chalk bag among them? Or, do you want to attach your chalk bag to your harness?

If you want to carry your bag so that you can easily move it around while you are climbing, then you need a bag with a belt attached. The belt is fixed around your waist and you can just bring the bag to the front when you need it and then move it right back again when you don’t.

If you want to carry your bag on a gear loop or want to attach it to a harness, look for a chalk bag that has sizable loops attached to the rim. You will use these loops to string the bag onto the harness or gear belt.

Chalk Bag Storage

Now, chalk isn’t the only thing that you need while on a rock climbing mission, although it is quite important. As a rule of thumb, seasoned climbers know not to leave chalk behind as they scale a slope. It is considered bad form and simply shouldn’t be done. This is why you need to carry a brush with you whenever you go climbing. Thus, for easy access, you should consider chalk bags with loops where you can place your brush while you are climbing.

There are some climbers who wish to take slightly larger items with them. If you don’t mind carrying a bit of additional weight, look for chalk bags that have exterior pockets. Although they aren’t too big, you should be able to fit keys and perhaps even a phone in there.

Chalk Bag Appearance

Chalk bags don’t just have to be about function anymore. These days, you are able to find bags that come in all sorts of colors and many have prints and patterns on them as well. There are even plush options with funny faces and more. So, don’t feel the need to stick with something somber or boring, simply because you feel that you have to.

What Type of Chalk Bag is Right for You?

In the end, it is only you who can really decide which size and shape are right for you. However, there are a few guidelines that can help you to make this decision:

If you are a beginner, you should try to carry as little weight as you can as this will making climbing easier for you. This is why a small chalk bag will often be more suitable for you. This type of chalk bag is also a great choice for climbing walls.

Now, of course, a small bag will only really work if you have small hands that can fit into the tiny opening. If you can’t get your hand through properly, you should look for a large chalk bag. The perk of a bigger bag is that you will also be able to carry more chalk with you.

Believe or not, how much you sweat will also have an impact on the type of bag that you buy. If you tend to sweat quite a bit, you will need a chalk bag with a larger opening. This will allow you to dip into your stash quickly and with less hassle.

Assessing Your Chalk Bag

It is imperative that you test out your chalk bag before you go climbing with it. The last thing that you need to do is to struggle midair trying to get the bag to work for you. So, the first thing you will need to do is to attempt to slide your hand into the chalk bag. With the smallest bag, you should be able to fit in at least three or four fingers. In standard bags, you should be able to place your entire hand in the bag.

The other thing that you should test out is how easy you find it to open and close the chalk bag. This will determine how quickly you can get to your chalk in a pinch. Try to get to the chalk with just one hand to see whether it is a feasible move or not.

So now you understand all of the factors that you have to consider when choosing a chalk bag for yourself.


Notes about this top 10 list


The list was last updated 19/09/2018.

The list shows the best reviewed chalk bags from a much bigger list of selected products. The list should not be considered a complete list of all available, excellent chalk bags

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.


About MightyGoods

Here at our site MightyGoods, we have checked thousands of reviews in order to build the biggest directory of backpacks, luggage, handbags and lots of other bags.

So far we have checked more than 2,1 million reviews!

Using our bag review summaries, we aim to help you find the perfect bag without having to spend a lot of time reading an endless list of reviews.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Tweet
Share
Pin