Top 10 Best Roll Top Backpacks in 2018

Roll top backpacks are popular, so it’s no surprise that there are quite a few models to choose between.

Not all of them are of the same high quality, so it pays to spend some time comparing the different brands and models.

Having checked hundreds of roll top backpack reviews, we can say that the Brooks Pickwick is the best choice for most people.

Brooks Pickwick

Brooks Pickwick

The best reviewed roll top backpack
Rated 4.82 out of 5

Check Price

PS: We have checked 1,811 reviews to make this top 10 list!
1Brooks PickwickBrooks Pickwick4.82Check Price
2Tumi Alpha Bravo London4.63Check Price
3Victorinox Altmont Classic4.51Check Price
4Chrome BarrageChrome Barrage4.41Check Price
5Duluth ScoutDuluth Scout4.29Check Price
6Timbuk2 HeistTimbuk2 Heist4.10Check Price
7Poler RetroPoler Retro3.54Check Price

How we rate the bags

We have checked 1,811 roll top backpack reviews, so we can show you the weighted average rating of all the bags.

Using the average ratings, you can check what all the reviewers think instead of just viewing the subjective opinion of one specific reviewer.

It’s much simplier to find the best bags that way.

Not sure what roll top backpacks to choose? Read on as we are going to take a closer look at each bag!

1 – Brooks Pickwick

5 review stars Rating 4.82 based on 24 reviews

Check Price

Brooks Pickwick

Here’s what the reviewers think about the Brooks Pickwick:

Reviewers like these things about the Brooks Pickwick

  • One user described it as smart looking and utilitarian.
  • Some users liked how the inside sleeves fits a full sized macbook pro.
  • Other reviewers thought it’s a nice vintage bag with a nice color.
  • Well built, solid zippers, perfect size, heavy duty stitching and materials, lightweight and long lasting materials are cited as the main reasons for choosing this bag.
  • Many users thought the wide straps are properly placed, no tangling, solidly made and high quality.
  • Some reviewers thought it has a clean look and simple design that goes well with some outfits.
  • Many owners liked how it’s very spacious yet very compact and sturdy.
  • Many agree that it’s got top notch quality and style and works great for commuting.
  • One user said that every detail of this bag was made with love.
  • An owner described it as an epic, aesthetically pleasing and functional bag.
  • Some users find the straps useful in keeping the bag’s weight well balanced.
  • Other reviewers find its straight forward simple design timeless.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • Some users thought it’s a bit expensive for a backpack.
  • Other reviewers said it would’ve been perfect if the straps are padded.

2 – Tumi Alpha Bravo London

4.5 review stars Rating 4.63 based on 296 reviews

Check Price

Here’s what the reviewers think about the Tumi Alpha Bravo London:

Reviewers like these things about the Tumi Alpha Bravo London

  • A lot of users are glad that it comes with great assortment of very well thought out pockets.
  • Many users thought it’s very well built, materials seem strong and long lasting.
  • Some users are so happy with how this bag can carry daily essentials even without using the expansion zipper, excellent carry capacity for commuting.
  • Many reviewers thought it’s a great size for air travel, the bag fits very well under the seat leaving good room for your feet.
  • Some reviewers thought the front pockets are easy access and great when travelling.
  • One user said that this bag has made his passport most accessible yet most secure in the bag.
  • many users find the bag with very sturdy quality, enough compartments to hold everything, separate sections for ipad and laptop.
  • Many users love the presence of intelligently sized pockets.
  • Some users describe it as seriously designed and very well crafted with quality materials.
  • One user finds the zippers very impressive.
  • One reviewers said the styling is clean and rugged yet still looks quite professional whether you’re wearing a suit or business casual.
  • Many users find the lining nice, the hardware quality is outstanding, stitching is straight and threads are thick.
  • A lot of reviewers thought the zippers and hardware look like they are built to last and also give the back a very masculine look due to their large size and utilitarian vibe.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • The bag is solid and great looking but comes with weak leather hooks for the strap.
  • One user said the bag is on the heavy side when loaded.

3 – Victorinox Altmont Classic

4.5 review stars Rating 4.51 based on 1208 reviews

Check Price

Here’s what the reviewers think about the Victorinox Altmont Classic:

Reviewers like these things about the Victorinox Altmont Classic

  • Users have noted that the Victorinox Altmont backpack provides laptop protection and organization for essentials.
  • Several users said that its main compartment features file divider and two stretch mesh side pockets.
  • Many of the reviewers indicated that its largest section in the back has padded spot for laptop and tablet.
  • Other reviewers noted the presence of pass-thru on the back.
  • Reviewers said that it is a slim designed bag to hold laptop, cables, & essentials.
  • Testers noted that it comes with a little tool that is a bottle opener/ screwdriver.
  • Other testers said that it is a lightweight bag with nice features.
  • They also noted that the bag includes a removable bag that can store cables and other stuff.
  • Testers recommended the use of the bag for small day trips.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • A reviewer found that it does not have a sternum strap.
  • Another reviewer noted that it has no water bottle holder.

4 – Chrome Barrage

4.5 review stars Rating 4.41 based on 62 reviews

Check Price

Chrome Barrage

Here’s what the reviewers think about the Chrome Barrage:

Reviewers like these things about the Chrome Barrage

  • Many reviewers commend the Chrome Barrage backpack for the optimal comfort it delivers.
  • Reviewers thought that the bag is durable.
  • Testers pointed out that the pack has a buckle closure.
  • Some users thought that it has an adjustable external cargo net system for storage.
  • Reviewers noted that it has an easy access side water bottle pockets.
  • Other reviewers thought that its internal sleeve pocket fits up to 15-inch laptops.
  • Testers pointed out that it has an ergonomic shoulder strap design with EVA foam back panel for improved fit and breathability.
  • Several of those who have tried the bag noted that its sternum strap is essential for load distribution.
  • Other users recommend the bag for travel and outdoor adventure.
  • Testers pointed out that it could carry a lot of things.
  • They also mentioned that it has a distinct and appealing design.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • A reviewer thought that the bag is narrow.
  • Another reviewer felt that the bag does not offer much organization options.

5 – Duluth Scout

4.5 review stars Rating 4.29 based on 116 reviews

Check Price

Duluth Scout

Here’s what the reviewers think about the Duluth Scout:

Reviewers like these things about the Duluth Scout

  • Many reviewers noted that the craftsmanship of Duluth Scout backpack is excellent based on their experience.
  • Other reviewers pointed out that the bag is lightweight.
  • They also said that it could hold a significant amount of stuff.
  • Many users reported that the bag offers the option of rolling the bag down in order to accommodate a small load.
  • Several reviewers found out that its fabric is durable.
  • Many of the users felt that it kept their things secure.
  • Users noted that the bag is comfortable to wear.
  • They pointed out that it rides snug against the back.
  • Several testers recommend the use of the bag for travel, commute, or for everyday use.
  • Reviewers said that the bag has an attractive design.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • A user said that it had no pockets inside the bag.
  • Another user thought that the straps are way too rigid.
  • A reviewer had issues with the inside stitches.

6 – Timbuk2 Heist

4 review stars Rating 4.10 based on 27 reviews

Check Price

Timbuk2 Heist

Here’s what the reviewers think about the Timbuk2 Heist:

Reviewers like these things about the Timbuk2 Heist

  • Many users said that there are pockets & slots for everything.
  • Many other users said that they use this bag for business and personal use.
  • Many other users said that it has a sleek design and it’s very durable.
  • Reviewers said that the inside is well organized.
  • Most users love the versatility of this bag.
  • Many users said that the construction is amazingly strong.
  • Users said that this is a nice size for all their daily needs.
  • Most reviewers said that the bag itself is plenty spacious.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • One user complained that the lining is black so it’s impossible to find anything inside.
  • Some users complained that the shoulder strap slips.
  • Another user said that the straps are too thin and uncomfortable.
  • Some other users said that the pack lacks a shoulder pad and a handle pad.

7 – Poler Retro

3.5 review stars Rating 3.54 based on 78 reviews

Check Price

Poler Retro

Here’s what the reviewers think about the Poler Retro:

Reviewers like these things about the Poler Retro

  • Many users agree that it’s a really good backpack for the price.
  • As student used it for class and camping trips and said she loved it so far.
  • Others are happy that it came on time and looks exactly like in the photos.
  • One user exclapimed this Poler bag is top notch.
  • A reviewer was so happy that he found what he was looking for in this bag: a retro backpack that has the look and feel of an old 70’s one but is functional and light.
  • Many users liked how light and roomy this pack is.
  • One of the favorite features of the bag are the side pouches which they can pull off too and function as toiletry bags during travels.
  • One reviewers who’ve used the bag for a while said it’s been his go-to bag for short-term travel, as well as camping/hiking trips.
  • Others praise it for its high-quality zippers and fairly spacious top pouch.
  • One owner recommends this bag to anyone looking for a multipurpose bag for activities like camping, short travels and hiking.

Reviewers don’t like these things

  • One user said he was a little disappointed that one of the straps doesn’t stay clamped.
  • One reviewer said it was more of a plastic type material than a canvas and with no additional accessory pockets inside.

More exciting bags

You might also be interested in these bag categories!

Notes about this top 10 list

The list was last updated 19/09/2018.

The list shows the best reviewed roll top backpacks from a much bigger list of selected products. The list should not be considered a complete list of all available, excellent roll top backpacks

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.

About MightyGoods

Here at our site MightyGoods, we have checked thousands of reviews in order to build the biggest directory of backpacks, luggage, handbags and lots of other bags.

So far we have checked more than 2,1 million reviews!

Using our bag review summaries, we aim to help you find the perfect bag without having to spend a lot of time reading an endless list of reviews.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *