Top 20 Best Reviewed Rolling Duffel Bags - Buyers Guide 2018

Travelling with a rolling duffel bag is often easier and more comfortable than travelling with a backpack.

Unfortunately not all duffel bags are of the same great quality, so it pays to spend some time comparing the different brands and models.

To help you choose, we have checked 23,065 reviews to find the best reviewed rolling duffel bags.

Check out the top 20 list below - and the top 3 most popular rolling duffel bags, if you just want to check out some of the most popular models (the models that most people end up buying).
How we rate the bags

We have checked thousands of reviews, so we can show you the weighted average rating of all the bags.

Using the average ratings, you can check what all the reviewers think instead of just viewing the subjective opinion of one specific reviewer.

It's much simplier to find the best bags that way.

Top 3 most popular rolling duffel bags 2018

Patagonia Black Hole
Patagonia Black Hole
Rated 4.7 based on 1,328 reviews.
The North Face Rolling Thunder
The North Face Rolling Thunder
Rated 4.6 based on 434 reviews.
Eagle Creek No Matter What
Eagle Creek No Matter What
Rated 4.4 based on 1,697 reviews.

Below is the top 20 list based on the thousands of reviews we have checked.

Top 20 rolling duffel bags 2018

Burton Wheelie
Burton Wheelie
2 models available. [31109] and 63
Size 40 L (2441 CI)
Burton logo
95 reviews

Patagonia Black Hole duffel
Patagonia Black Hole
5 models available. 120, 25, 45, 60 and 90
Size 25-120 L (1526-7323 CI)
Patagonia logo
1,328 reviews

Patagonia Headway duffel
Patagonia Headway
4 models available. 22, 40, 45 and 70
Size 22-70 L (1343-4272 CI)
Patagonia logo
236 reviews

The North Face Rolling Thunder duffel
The North Face Rolling Thunder
4 models available. 19, 22, 30 and 36
The north face logo
434 reviews

Eagle Creek Load Warrior
Eagle Creek Load Warrior
7 models available. 20, 22, 25, 26, 28, 29 and 32
Size 42 L (2563 CI)
Eagle creek logo
364 reviews

Timbuk2 Quest duffel
Timbuk2 logo
8 reviews

Timbuk2 Wingman duffel
Timbuk2 Wingman
2 models available. [31093] and 2
Size 40 L (2441 CI)
Timbuk2 logo
295 reviews

Carhartt Legacy
Carhartt logo
513 reviews

Pacsafe Toursafe
Pacsafe Toursafe
5 models available. [31125], at21, at25, at29 and exp34
Size 42 L (2563 CI)
Pacsafe logo
156 reviews

Sakroots Artist Circle
Sakroots logo
6,567 reviews

Eagle Creek Morphus duffel
Eagle Creek Morphus
2 models available. 22 and 30
Size 48 L (2929 CI)
Eagle creek logo
31 reviews

High Sierra Access duffel
High Sierra Access
3 models available. 17, 26 and 32
Size 100 L (6102 CI)
High sierra logo
6,057 reviews

Eagle Creek Gear Warrior duffel
Eagle Creek Gear Warrior
4 models available. 22, 26, 29 and 32
Size 38-92 L (2319-5614 CI)
Eagle creek logo
395 reviews

Eagle Creek No Matter What duffel
Eagle Creek No Matter What
3 models available. 20, 22 and 28
Size 38-77 L (2319-4699 CI)
Eagle creek logo
1,697 reviews

Timbuk2 Navigator duffel
Timbuk2 Navigator
Size 36 L (2197 CI)
Timbuk2 logo
148 reviews

Thule Crossover duffel
Thule Crossover
5 models available. 25, 32, 38, 40 and 87
Size 25-87 L (1526-5309 CI)
Thule logo
1,048 reviews

High Sierra AT8 duffel
High sierra logo
22 reviews

Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler duffel
Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler
4 models available. 120, 45, 60 and 90
Size 45-120 L (2746-7323 CI)
Eagle creek logo
803 reviews

Pacsafe Duffelsafe duffel
Pacsafe Duffelsafe
5 models available. [31124], at100, at120, at45 and at80
Size 80 L (4882 CI)
Pacsafe logo
41 reviews

Calpak Plato duffel
Calpak Plato
Size 41 L (2502 CI)
Calpak logo
135 reviews

Samsonite Andante duffel
Samsonite logo
2,675 reviews

Pacsafe Pouchsafe duffel
Pacsafe Pouchsafe
Size 25 L (1526 CI)
Pacsafe logo
17 reviews

Review Summary

23,065 reviews of bags checked.

Average rating is 4.4 out of 5.
5 star
4 star
3 star
2 star
1 star

Top 10 rolling duffel brands

The 10 highest rated rolling duffel brands based on the 23,065 reviews we have checked + the highest rated bag from each brand.

BrandAverage ratingTop rolling duffel
Burton4.8Burton Wheelie
Patagonia4.7Patagonia Black Hole
The North Face4.6The North Face Rolling Thunder
Carhartt4.5Carhartt Legacy
Sakroots4.5Sakroots Artist Circle
Timbuk24.4Timbuk2 Quest
High Sierra4.4High Sierra Access
Eagle Creek4.4Eagle Creek Load Warrior
Thule4.4Thule Crossover
Pacsafe4.4Pacsafe Toursafe

Related Ranking Lists

The duffel bag is undoubtedly one of the most versatile pieces of luggage that you can own. It makes traveling by vehicle an absolute breeze and is perfect for all types of adventures. This is why the rolling duffel bag is just the thing you need if you are headed out on vacation, particularly by plane.

Of course, when deciding on a rolling duffel bag, there are a few more things to take into consideration such as weight and support system. In this article, we take the opportunity to discuss this and more. If you want a rolling duffel bag to be your next piece of luggage, these are the guidelines that you will need to follow.

Your Guidelines to Choosing the Ideal Rolling Duffel Bag for You (Buyers Guide)

For the longest time, people relied on traditional duffel bags, even when they were traveling by plane. The rolling duffel bag, though, opens up a whole new world of opportunities for you, which makes it even easier for you to get from point A to point B. If you are interested in finding out all that you can about this type of duffel bag, here is what you need to know:

The Advantages of Travel Duffel Bags

So, why would you choose a wheeled duffel bag over other luggage options available to you? You may be surprised to learn that there are actually a lot of advantages associated with this type of bag. For instance, they tend to be a lot lighter than suitcases and other pieces of luggage. This is quite handy considering that airlines are beginning to charge more and more for checked luggage.

The other benefit of this type of bag is that it is quite durable despite its low weight. This makes it the ideal accompaniment for more adventurous trips where you might need to drag the bag through rough terrain. What really makes this type of bag such a great choice though is just how easy it is to wheel around. You will have no problem transporting it across large stretches as you will have to make very little effort on your part.

Determining the Right Sized Duffel Bag for You

When referring to a travel duffel bag, you have to take the dimensions as well as the capacity into consideration. This is especially important if you are traveling by plane and have to adhere to certain size and weight requirements.


Now, when trying to figure out what dimensions are a good option for you, the first thing you will need to know is if you want your bag to be carry-on luggage or checked luggage. If you want a bag to go as checked luggage, there aren’t too many size restrictions. As long as you avoid extra-large duffel bags, you will not have to pay any fees associated with oversized luggage.

On the other hand, if you want to take your rolling duffel bag, you need to pay attention to the dimensions. Usually, it is a good idea to avoid a duffel that is longer than twenty-two inches. You should also check that the handles and wheels don’t add too much height to the bag either. You will also need to check that the width isn’t too long either – typically no more than ten inches. The final measurement to consult is the height of the bag which should be less than fifteen inches when it is fully packed.


The next thing that you will need to think about is just how much you are able to fit into your rolling duffel bag. Of course, for this, you will need to know how long your trip is and what you want to take. In this case, the travel duffel bags can be categorized into small, medium, large, and extra-large bags.

  • Small (40 – 45 liters): These duffel bags are a good choice for an overnight or weekend trip and can fit in several items of clothing and perhaps even shoes and a camera.
  • Medium (50 – 85 liters): While these bags do look compact, you should be able to pack for several days at a time and be able to take clothes, shoes, and a few other accessories with you.
  • Large (90 – 120 liters): These bags should be able to contain all of the clothes and accessories that you will need for a week, perhaps even longer.
  • Extra-large (130+ liters): These bags are an excellent option for people who want to take as much as they possibly can. Of course, you still need to keep an eye out for the weight restrictions placed by airlines.

Size vs. Weight

The good thing about most rolling duffel bags is that they are relatively light. At the same time, the bigger the piece of luggage that you choose, the heavier that it will be. The reason that the weight of the bag should be taken into consideration is because of the weight restrictions that are placed on carry-on and checked luggage. The heavier that the bag is, by itself, the less that you can pack into it. So, it is important to find a balance between the two.

Understanding the Materials Used in Rolling Duffel Bags

Rolling duffel bags can be made from all types of materials although they are more commonly made of nylon and polyester, at the moment. However, manufacturers are always coming with new blends so that the bags end up lighter but also tougher. Since you are most likely to come across the two materials mentioned, though, let’s focus on those.

If your main goal is to have a travel duffel bag that is as light as possible, then polyester will be a good choice for you and, in fact, is what many of the cheaper rolling duffel bags are made from. While you may have to forego a little bit of durability, this is not always the case. In fact, some wheeled duffel bags are made from rip-stop polyester that makes it a lot more abrasion resistant.

Nylon isn’t used as often but is relatively traditional with more expensive duffel bags. The main advantage here is the durability although these bags can be a little heavier too. If you want to ensure that your bag is as durable as possible, you should invest in rip-stop nylon options.


Not all rolling duffel bags require weatherproofing. If you are on the kind of vacation that means that a covered roof is only moments away, you will not have to shell out for this kind of luxury. However, if you are planning on heading out into more remote areas where you are sure to encounter a few showers, then it is a good idea to look into this feature. Since most materials aren’t waterproof by themselves, you should consider those with a waterproof coating that will repel water. Of course, you will also need to check that the zippers will not let water in as well.

Wheels and Stability

As you can imagine, one of the most important aspects of a rolling duffel bag is its wheels. So, before you make your decision regarding a particular bag, it will definitely pay off for you to take a quick peek at them. Really, there are only two main requirements that you should look for.

You should stay away from duffel bags with small wheels and should focus on models with larger wheels instead. Large wheels are less likely to get caught in small cracks or breaks in the ground and will be easier for you to maneuver. The other thing to look at is the durability of the wheels – you will need to ensure that they are made from a strong, durable plastic and that they will not crack easily. This is particularly important if the duffel bag is quite large and if you will be packing it with a lot of items.


With rolling duffel bags, the most popular way to keep them is standing upright. Due to this, stability can be an important feature to look for in a travel duffel bag. If you want to ensure that your duffel bag will stand on its own and will not tip over, then you should look for two plastic pieces parallel to the wheels of the bag. These act as a support system for your duffel bag and holds it upright.

Is the Bag Easy to Pack?

There is little use in having a travel duffel bag that is not easy to pack. So, what constitutes a bag that is “pack-able”? The opening of the bag certainly plays a role – the larger that it is, the easier it is to store your items neatly.

Another helpful feature though is compartments and pockets. There are a few advantages to this. Internal pockets help to separate your items from one another which makes them easier to find later on. These also come in handy if there are certain items that you would rather not mix (dirty shoes and clothing, for instance). External pockets are quite useful on carry-on bags since they keep important items on hand at all times.

If you want to pack a lot of items, then having a rolling duffel bag that has an expandable main compartment can work in your favor. At the same time, compression straps are a good feature to keep an eye out for as well. These straps keep all of the items in place while also ensuring that the bag can be flattened enough to fit into various spaces. This feature can also prevent your luggage from being labeled as excess baggage too.

The Handles

When talking about rolling duffel bags, there are actually several handles that you could be referring to. The most notable one, of course, is the handle that is on top of the case that can be lengthened or retracted depending on how you are handling the bags. With this one, you should check the durability of it to ensure that it can withstand a little bit of rough handling, particularly with larger and heavier duffel bags.

The other handles to think about are the ones on either side of the duffel bag. You use these to pick the bags up and carry them horizontally, parallel to the ground. Look for sturdy designs that are either wide or padded so that they are more comfortable to hold.

Some rolling duffel bags come with shoulder straps that allow you to hoist the bag on your back with a diagonal strap across your back. These can work well for lighter and smaller bags so that they can be carried across uneven terrain.

These are the things that you will need to pay attention to when considering rolling duffel bags. After going through each step, you will find it easier to get the bag that you need.

Last updated on March 19, 2018

Comments are closed.