MightyGoods > Coach > Coach Madison

Coach Madison Reviews Summary and Buyer's Guide

Last updated May 13, 2019

based on 51 reviews

We have checked tens of reviews and found 8 reasons to buy the Madison - and 2 reasons NOT to buy it.

Check all the pros and cons here.

83% of the reviewers give the Coach Madison a good or excellent rating!

Excellent (74%)
Good (9%)
Average (1%)
Poor (1%)
Bad (11%)

Reviews Summary

Here's what the reviewers think about the Coach Madison:

Reviewers like these things about the Coach Madison

  • Some users chose the bag for its sleek design and fabtastic compartments for organization.
  • A lot of users thought it's the perfect size, not large enough to be imposing on smaller frames and not so small.
  • Some reviewers love its satin lining.
  • Others love the modest shine of the hardware.
  • Some reviewers are surprised to find the bag lightweight for its size.
  • Others find the length of the strap adequate.
  • Many users love that the bag can be worn as a crossbody, over the shoulder or carried by the tote handles.
  • Others like how the short handles can be fully folded down.

Reviewers don't like these things

  • Some users find the straps too short for those with longer torso.
  • Others find it a bit expensive for what it is.


Crowdsourced specs across all Coach Madison models and sizes:

Weight iconWeight1.5 oz (0.7 kg)
Length iconLength12 in (30 cm)
Width6 in (15 cm)
Height8 in (20 cm)

Popular Models

Coach Madison Phoebe

75% choose the Coach Madison Phoebe

75 %
Colors and combinations:


Coach Madison Sophia

25% choose the Coach Madison Sophia

25 %
Colors and combinations:


Coach Madison phoebe vs Madison sophia

The two most popular Coach Madison models are the Madison phoebe and the Madison sophia, so let's compare them:

The Madison phoebe
Coach Madison Phoebe

The Madison sophia
Coach Madison Sophia

Popularity and Prices

In total, 100% of the people interested in the Coach Madison bags choose one of these two models. The most popular choice is the Madison phoebe which is choosen by 75% (3 times as many as the 25% that choose the Madison sophia).

Madison phoebeMadison sophia
Most popular

Features and Colors

Both models are available in pink. Only the Madison phoebe is available in brown, red and white. Only the Madison sophia is available in black and grey.


vs Coach Bags

The Coach Madison ranks #9 compared with the other Coach bags.

7Coach Edie
Coach Edie
8Coach Signature
Coach Signature
9Coach Madison
Coach Madison
10Coach Swagger
Coach Swagger
11Coach Bleecker
Coach Bleecker

vs All Bags

The Coach Madison ranks #2122 compared with all the bags we have checked.

2120Kate Spade Stacy
Kate Spade Stacy
2121Coach Madison
Coach Madison
2122Otterbox Defender
Otterbox Defender
2123Kavu Pack Attack
Kavu Pack Attack
2124American Flyer Fleur de Lis
American Flyer Fleur de Lis

Bag ID 40037. Images from Amazon Product Advertising API and shop datafeeds.

Last updated on May 13, 2019