MightyGoods > Herschel > Herschel Barlow

Herschel Barlow Reviews Summary and Buyer's Guide

This bag has very few reviews, so we haven't ranked it.

Last updated April 2019

We have checked a few reviews and found 13 reasons to buy the Barlow - and 3 reasons NOT to buy it.

Check all the pros and cons here.

No deals foundCheck Amazon

Reviews Summary

Here's what the reviewers think about the Herschel Barlow:

Reviewers like these things about the Herschel Barlow

  • Most users said that this bag is sturdy and practical, and it looks nice.
  • Many reviewers said that it is a perfect pack for commuting, hiking, taking the dog places.
  • Many users said that the back and straps are rigid and padded with mesh over foam. They make it comfortable to carry heavy things.
  • There are a few tiny reflective elements, tiny loops on the bottom and top.
  • Most reviewers agreed that it's slim and expands upwards instead of outwards so it doesn't knock into things when getting onto the bus, etc.
  • Many users said that the top loading style allows them to over-stuff it if needed while still protecting its contents.
  • One great feature mentioned by many users is that there is a sternum strap that adjusts lengthwise and slides up and down the shoulder straps.
  • Reviewers said that the shoulder straps and sternum strap all have an elastic sleeve to hold coiled extra strap after everything is tightened down.
  • Many users said that the laptop sleeve can fit a 15' Mac book, charger, and a folder of papers in the laptop sleeve without trouble.
  • Another great feature mentioned by many users is that the laptop sleeve has a smaller pocket on the outside to hold a slim phone.
  • Another fantastic feature mentioned by the users is that it has a hook for keys Above the laptop sleeve.
  • Many users said that there is a a mini daisy chain to hook a hydration pack or whatever else.
  • Users said that there is one large compartment with laptop sleeve, one small compartment in top flap for small easy access items and one tiny bottom compartment for rain-fly in it.

Reviewers don't like these things

  • One user complained that the strong mesh laptop sleeve is not padded.
  • Another user said that it does not have lots of pockets.
  • Another user complained that the draw string cap broke early.


Crowdsourced specs across all Herschel Barlow models and sizes:

Weight iconWeight2.5 oz (1.1 kg)
Length iconLength11 in (28 cm)
Width6-10 in (15-25 cm)
Height17-18 in (43-46 cm)

Popular Models

Herschel Barlow Large

100% choose the Herschel Barlow Large

100 %
Colors and combinations:


Weight iconWeight2.5 oz (1.1 kg)
Length iconLength11 in (28 cm)
Width10 in (25 cm)
Height17 in (43 cm)

Selected Reviews

Rush Faster

The Herschel Barlow is a solid choice. It’s great if you are a cyclist who needs a trusty pack for traversing the city, or you are just looking for a discrete pack for uni or work.

Posted 4 August 2017 - Read full review

Become a reviewer

Bag ID 31346. Images from Amazon Product Advertising API and shop datafeeds.

Last updated on April 19, 2019