MightyGoods > Herschel > Herschel Retreat

Herschel Retreat Reviews Summary and Buyer's Guide

Last updated May 13, 2019

4.15
based on 2,980 reviews


We have checked thousands of reviews and found 9 reasons to buy the Retreat - and 2 reasons NOT to buy it.

Check all the pros and cons here.


86% of the reviewers give the Herschel Retreat a good or excellent rating!

Excellent (72%)
Good (14%)
Average (6%)
Poor (3%)
Bad (2%)





Reviews Summary


Here's what the reviewers think about the Herschel Retreat:

Reviewers like these things about the Herschel Retreat

  • Many users thought it's well constructed, comes with excellent padding and hold a ton.
  • A lot of users love how the thick padding keeps their laptop secure.
  • Some users chose this bag for its solid quality and style.
  • Many reviewers love how their laptop fits neatly in the compartment.
  • A lot of users find the well cushioned straps very useful in distributing the weight of the pack.
  • Color combination is also a favorite feature among users.
  • Other users love how it carries all their work and personal essentials around.
  • Some reviewers appreciate the magnetic strap closure with metal pin clips.
  • Other users also love the striped fabric liner.

Reviewers don't like these things

  • Some users wish there were more internal pockets.
  • Others said the button snaps came off on first use.



Specs


Crowdsourced specs across all Herschel Retreat models and sizes:

Laptop iconLaptop SizeMax. 15 inches


The bag is recommended for these activities:

Travel
Hiking
Cycling
School
Backpacking
Sport



Feature Summary


Many sources mention these Herschel Retreat features:
  • Laptop compartment

Actual features depends on the model, so check the features before you buy.


Rankings


vs Herschel Bags

The Herschel Retreat ranks #6 compared with the other Herschel bags.

Top 20% Herschel bag

4Herschel Pop Quiz
4.19
Herschel Pop Quiz
5Herschel Iona
4.19
Herschel Iona
6Herschel Retreat
4.15
Herschel Retreat
7Herschel Charlie
4.15
Herschel Charlie
8Herschel Classic
4.12
Herschel Classic

vs All Bags

The Herschel Retreat ranks #830 compared with all the bags we have checked.

Top 30% bag

828Kipling Klara
4.15
Kipling Klara
829Herschel Retreat
4.15
Herschel Retreat
830The North Face Tallac
4.15
The North Face Tallac
831Kenneth Cole Reaction No Looking Back
4.15
Kenneth Cole Reaction No Looking Back
832Bellroy Travel
4.15
Bellroy Travel



Vs Other Bags


Crowdsourced comparisons of the Herschel Retreat vs 3 other, similar bags.

Many sources mention this feature
Some sources mention this feature


Herschel Retreat vs Herschel Dawson


Herschel Retreat
Herschel Retreat

4.15
BEST
Based on 2,980 reviews
Capacity:
Weight:
Price: $$


Herschel Dawson
Herschel Dawson

3.52

Based on 483 reviews

Capacity:
Weight: 0 oz
Price: $$

  • The Retreat is rated somewhat better than the Dawson.
  • In total, we have checked and analyzed 3,463 reviews of the two bags.

FeatureRetreatDawson
Carry-on size
Laptop compartment
Organizer panel

Both bags are available in these colors:
Black
Blue
Grey
Red

Only the Retreat is available in these colors:
Green
White




Herschel Retreat vs Herschel Little America


Herschel Retreat
Herschel Retreat

4.15
BEST
Based on 2,980 reviews
Capacity:
Weight:
Price: $$


Herschel Little America
Herschel Little America

4.00

Based on 9,331 reviews

Capacity:
Weight: 1.6-1.95 oz
Price: $$

  • The Retreat is rated a little bit better than the Little America.
  • In total, we have checked and analyzed 12,311 reviews of the two bags.

FeatureRetreatLittle America
Laptop compartment
Media pocket

Both bags are available in these colors:
Black
Blue
Grey
Green
White
Red

Only the Little America is available in these colors:
Brown

Herschel's offerings are great for those who want mountaineering backpacks that won't fail them on the trail. Little America is just right for carrying the important things you'll need on a hike. Water bottles, gear, and clothes will fit in without any problems or need for special packing.

The Herschel Retreat is similar to the Little America backpack but with a sturdier build. This makes the Herchel ideal for carrying a heavier load at the cost of a thicker build. Choose the Herschel if you need to pack some heavy equipment, but if you don't need that you'll find the Little America works just fine.


Herschel Retreat vs Herschel Pop Quiz


Herschel Retreat
Herschel Retreat

4.15

Based on 2,980 reviews
Capacity:
Weight:
Price: $$


Herschel Pop Quiz
Herschel Pop Quiz

4.19
BEST
Based on 3,566 reviews

Capacity:
Weight: 1.2-1.6 oz
Price: $$

  • The Retreat is rated about the same as the Pop Quiz.
  • In total, we have checked and analyzed 6,546 reviews of the two bags.

FeatureRetreatPop Quiz
Laptop compartment
Media pocket
Waterproof

Both bags are available in these colors:
Black
Blue
Grey
White

Only the Retreat is available in these colors:
Green
Red





Bag ID 35349. Images from Amazon Product Advertising API and shop datafeeds.

Last updated on May 13, 2019